MONTAGE: Small town in the big city.

As an antidote to my previous, text-heavy post, I offer one that focuses almost entirely on images, looking at remnants of small towns and rural communities in Marion County that have long ago been engulfed by the continuous urbanization of the city of Indianapolis. I’m not the first to attempt this. Urban Indy has featured several excellent posts over the past few months where he ventured into small-town enclaves such as New Augusta, Acton, Lawrence, and West Newton. In this feature on other historic rural enclaves in Marion County, I have tried to avoid those that other blogs have featured, or those that seem to be the most widely known. Instead, I have scrutinized the ones that are the most obscure—those for which only a few vestiges of old buildings, a rail crossing, or some other telltale indicator remain. Therefore these photos won’t offer nearly as much great historic architecture as the posts at Urban Indy, but hopefully they will inform viewers how abundant these rich little corners really are.

Mars Hill

I’ll first begin on the southwest side, with one of the largest and better known enclaves, Mars Hill, centered around the intersection of Kentucky Avenue and Holt Road., with some of the best-maintained commercial structures visible in this hastily taken photo:
rural enclaves Mars HillAccording to the timeline provided by The Polis Center, Mars Hill originated as a rural community that a group of Indianapolis businessmen platted and hoped to develop in 1911 into a thriving industrial suburb—a manufacturing center to rival Gary. Even as its population quickly swelled to over 500—then expanded again in the 1940s with the growth of the nearby Alison plant—it remained unincorporated until the 1970 Unigov initiative. Only at this point did the City hoped to improve what had long been a low- to working-class neighborhood through paved streets and fully functional water and sewage systems. Today, the neighborhood is poised in the heart of Indianapolis’ southwest industrial corridor. Close by are plenty of once-mighty properties with the archetypal Rottweilers behind chain link fences:

rural enclaves Mars Hill
Mars Hill, though, remains predominantly residential, so that the surviving manufacturing centers are usually a 5 minute car drive away. Within Mars Hill, a handful of corner convenience stores are within walking distance (many vacant):

rural enclaves Mars Hill

A number of churches survive in the neighborhood. At one point, Mars Hill was the hub of the city’s Romanian Baptist community.
rural enclaves Mars Hill
It seems unlikely that Mars Hill will enjoy a revival any time soon; the employment base in the area has shrunk through deindustrialization. It’s a shame, because the tree canopy is often mature, and both Farnsworth and Troy Avenue (seen in photos above) could offer a viable commercial Main Street.

Some areas of Mars Hill show traces of residential abandonment, but by and large the neighborhood remains occupied. Below is one of the more picturesque blocks:
rural enclaves Mars Hill


Only a half mile northwest of Mars Hill along Kentucky Avenue is the much smaller community of Maywood, which predominantly consists of a commercial intersection (at Tibbs Avenue and Maywood Road) and a cluster of houses surrounding it. Here’s the heart of this formerly rural hamlet looking to the northeast:
rural enclaves Maywood
And here’s the same intersection looking to the southwest:

Unlike Mars Hill, Maywood shows no evidence of being tied to a railway. While it may have served as a bedroom community in the peak days of the interurban, it also could have been a larger agrarian settlement at one point, only to have lost most of its growth options through the establishment of the Rolls Royce plant to the north. A watering hole seems to survive:
rural enclaves Maywood
The antique market appears to have been less successful:


rural enclaves Mickleyville
This largely invisible community a bit north of Mars Hill, approximately centered around the intersection of Lynhurst Drive and Minnesota Street, most likely originated as a large farm plot owned by the Mickley family, perhaps centered around a depot when it evolved into a true settlement. While the railroad still survives, few if any older structures remain, outside of St. Joseph’s Catholic Church.

Most of the homes appear to date from the 1940s and 1950s. It’s likely that the construction if Interstate 465 severed the neighborhood in half. A few older commercial buildings flush with the lot line remain, where the residential local streets meet Washington Street (Highway 40).


Lynhurst Drive remains one of the most prominent north-south arterial streets on the west side, but how did it get its name? The closest approximation of the Lynhurst neighborhood seems to center on the street’s intersection with Rockville Road and the residential community just south of it (and north of Mickleyville), around the area featured in the picture below:

Only a few older structures at that intersection give any hint of an older community.
rural enclaves Lynhurstrural enclaves Lynhurst
For such a prominent street, the actual Lynhurst neighborhood is effectively buried. The stable working class area that ramifies from this intersection seems to date from the 1940s:

It directly abuts another small neighborhood called Garden City, for which even less information is available. (The photo above may technically fall into what residents of the area consider the Garden City neighborhood, but beyond this, I have so little information that I could not even begin to document anything with photographs.)


Far to the west of Lynhurst Drive, near the boundary of Marion County, sits one of the more plainly visible rural enclaves, at the point where Washington Street (Highway 40) intersects Bridgeport Road. A few vestiges of an old rail stop remain, including the still operative post office:
rural enclaves Bridgeport
The homes themselves evoke early 20th century farming cottages, but the hamlet of only five roads has sacrificed much of its rural character since the streets have been upgraded from local to collectors, accommodating high-speed traffic.
rural enclaves Bridgeport
At the eastern edge of the Bridgeport rural enclave, along Washington Street, is an old public school that appears half vacated and shuttered. On this gray day at the end of December, however, it still had lights in the upper levels and cars were parked in the lot.

The Ryder truck in the background of the second picture suggests that some further loading and unloading was taking place. Perhaps the school authorities are vacating the remainder of the building. According to Google Street View, the property has looked this way for at least a few years, but it is unlikely the Bridgeport environs are going to be growing in population any time soon.


So little of this rural settlement remains that it is impossible to tell if it was ever an organized community. It sits approximately at the intersections of 30th Street, Kessler Boulevard North Drive, and Tibbs Avenue, stretching southward to Lafayette Road. The oldest visible institution is Cardinal Ritter High School and the adjacent St. Michael’s Church.
rural enclaves Flackville
Most homes here appear to date from the 1950s. The one unquestionable reminder that Flackville was once an identifiable place (if never an incorporated town) is an old school, no doubt shuttered at least twenty years ago, that intermittently has enjoyed relatively recent incarnations as a bingo parlor, among other things.
rural enclaves Flackville


This community has been erased, for all intents and purposes. What survives is Snacks Crossing Elementary School in Pike Township, at the intersection of Moller Road and 56th Street. About a half mile south, at Moller Road and 52nd Street, is a cluster of homes on broad lots that most likely is all that survives of Snacks.
rural enclaves Snacks
In the background of this photo, through the trees to the right, is the discernible steeple of the community church, Bethel United Methodist—the closest evidence of any historic architecture in Snacks.

Its cemetery sits across the street from the church, visible on the left of the photo below, while a few more homes from what likely belongs to the Snacks community sit to the right.
rural enclaves Snacks
Even the historic Bethel United Methodist has been vaguely subsumed by a contemporary alternative; the larger, modern church building sits in the foreground of this photo:
rural enclaves Snacks

University Heights

The south side of Marion County doesn’t offer quite the array of old rural enclaves that the Westside boasts, but I have featured the classy streetcar suburb of Homecroft in an earlier post. And the Town of Southport is widely known as a separately incorporated enclave, surrounded by the City of Indianapolis. Other bloggers such has M. Heidelberger have documented the town far more capably than I can, but I haven’t seen much coverage of University Heights, the community immediately south of the University of Indianapolis, at Shelby Street, Hanna Avenue, and Madison Avenue, which bears all evidence of an old streetcar suburb. I could find little verifiable history on the neighborhood, but it appears to derive from an agreement between an early 20th century land developer who negotiated with the university’s trustees to establish a residential neighborhood of over 400 lots after donating land and money for the preliminary buildings.

rural enclaves University Heights
Part of the University spreads south of Hanna Avenue, intermingling with homes nearby:
rural enclaves University Heights
The point where the railroad crosses Hanna and Shelby simultaneously seems the suitable site for an interurban stop, with a few supporting commercial structures still in operation.
rural enclaves University Heights rural enclaves University Heights
Though shellacked with white acrylic, the Little Shop of Horrors building undoubtedly dates from the time when University Heights was a distant suburban community.


Possibly as far from University Heights as one can get and still be in Marion County, the far northeastern community of Oaklandon retains a considerable number of old commercial buildings, at the intersection of Pendleton Pike and Oaklandon Road. Most of the heart of the community focuses on its intersection of Oaklandon Road with an old Conrail line. It is one of the less obscure rural enclaves, and it’s surrounded by suburbia to the north, east, and west.
 rural enclaves Oaklandon
The majority of this community appears very well-maintained and preserved—particularly remarkable considering it sacrificed any political autonomy it might have had, after 1970’s Unigov.
 rural enclaves Oaklandon

 rural enclaves OaklandonBad weather and the encroaching dusk prevented me from taking more lingering photos.
 rural enclaves Oaklandon rural enclaves Oaklandon
The community organized itself enough to dedicate and build a pocket park at the foot of the old water tower.

This blurry Unitarian Universalist church is one of several in the area that reference Oaklandon in its name.

The small-town character dissolves rapidly into suburbia on the north side of the railroad tracks, though the heavily-skylighted structure in the background clearly dates from Oaklandon’s origins as an old rail stop.
rural enclaves Oaklandon


My favorite of all of these old rural enclaves has to be Julietta, not because it’s visually remarkable but because it’s so obscure. It sits on the eastern edge of town, where Brookville Road (Highway 52) meets Carroll Road, the line between Marion and Hancock Counties. It consists of three streets, each only one block in length, and a railway crossing. Many of the houses are visibly turn-of-the-century.

rural enclaves Julietta
According to the maps, the street beyond the tracks used to cross and meet with the road on which I am standing; now they form two separate dead ends.
rural enclaves Julietta
Here’s looking at that same dead end from the perspective of the street itself, Nicolai Road:

Some of the older homes (there are less than a dozen) are impeccably maintained:

What appears to be an old chapel might seem abandoned, but the door on the front isn’t sealed, nor are the windows on the side:

It’s possible that Julietta at one point had more homes, but the ones closest to Brookville Road were razed to make way for this park:

The most provocative aspect of this community are the grounds of what I believe is the former Julietta Home for the Aged, a sprawling structure with a new name and use that seems positively Orwellian:

This concludes my report. Dig a little further and I’m sure there are other rural enclaves within Indianapolis worthy of photo documentation. Here are a few that come to mind:
Wanamaker – old village in the center of Franklin Township along Southeastern Avenue and Northeastern Avenue, it has all the makings of a rail stop without any evidence of a railway, but is probably among the best known rural enclaves south of Washington Street
Washington Place – not sure about this, but it could be another streetcar suburb on the east side of town at the intersection of Washington Street and Franklin Road, stretching eastward to Post Road. Much of the south side of Washington Street here has given way to suburban development
Castleton – it was a rail stop–one of the most rural enclaves–before it became a megamall
Nora – a few blocks of old rural homes survive; the rest has been converted to strip malls and the campus of North Central High School
Clermont – an “included town” since Unigov, it retains much of its identity and is widely known on the far west side
Sunshine Gardens – a rural outpost of broadly spaced homes at the intersection of Epler Avenue and Concord Street on the south side
Camby – another of the rural enclaves, at the intersection of Camby Road and Kentucky Avenue, widely known among people in Decatur Township

I’m sure I’m forgetting quite a few other rural enclaves and would be happy to take suggestions. Happy New Year!

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email

18 thoughts on “MONTAGE: Small town in the big city.

  1. AmericanDirt

    Good point. I have never been to that area. I know that it was considered an “included town” that basically was absorbed by Unigov, but I don’t know if it has any old architectural remnants that show that it once was a freestanding community. Same with places like Rocky Ripple, Meridian Hills, Williams Creek, Wynnedale, etc.

  2. Curt

    This was an awesome write up. One passes through some of these areas without ever appreciating the history or thinking about it when we complain about how bad it may look or “How did it ever get this way?” Sometimes, that backstory tells all. Good job!

  3. John M

    I live about a mile away from it, but I had no idea that Warren Park was an included town as opposed to a mere neighborhood. As far as I can tell, the boundaries include a bunch of 40s-60s housing stock with a few isolated older homes, a couple of apartment complexes, and some strip malls and car dealerships on the west side of Shadeland between 10th and 16th. If there ever was any kind of older commercial district, it’s long gone. Frankly, WP seems indistinguishable from other clusters of postwar subdivisions in Warren Township. I’m sure one of your readers knows the history of Warren Park, but at first blush it doesn’t seem to have much in common with the absorbed towns documented in the post.

    A look at the Indianapolis aerial photos from 1941 reveals little but farmland in the area now considered Warren Park, much like the rest of Warren Township, and nothing that looks to my eye like any sort of Main Street. Of course, the neighborhoods south of 10th Street and west of Arlington already were developed as they are today. My guess is that for whatever reason, the postwar developers of this area decided to incorporate. In the 1956 aerial photos, the residential areas were pretty well built out, with Eastgate Mall and the cloverleaf at Washington and Shadeland apparently under construction. In 1962, Eastgate was open, but the west side of Shadeland looks to have been farm fields. By 1972, the commercial development on Shadeland between 10th and 16th looks much as it does today.

  4. cdc guy

    Probably the oldest “development” in Warren Park is the old Hilltopper Tavern and the Anderson Cemetery, both just west of Pleasant Run on 10th St.

    That’s if you don’t count the historic Askren farmhouse, just east of Raytheon on the north side of 16th.

    I think Warren Park’s story is “aspirational suburb that got bypassed”. There is actually some significant residential density there, as there are lots of 40’s, 50’s, and 60’s apartments just north of 10th from Arlington to Shadeland.

  5. John M

    Good point about the Hilltopper, CDC. I drive past it often, and the newish vinyl siding camouflages just how old it is. Technically, however, both the Anderson Cemetery and the Askren farmhouse are outside the boundaries of Warren Park “proper.”

  6. cdc guy

    My bad: I thought the Warren Park sign along eastbound 10th was at the western edge of the south portion of the Anderson Cemetery, and that both sides of Pleasant Run were within its boundaries. I used to regularly travel that part of 10th but it’s been a few years.

  7. AmericanDirt

    Thanks for all your thoughtful posts. You’ve convinced me I need to check this part of town out more thoroughly sometime soon, if I have the opportunity. Another friend justifiably recognized Irvington as a similar enclave, which of course is a terrific example but I’m sure has been covered by other bloggers (including some who no doubt live there).

  8. cdc guy

    Irvington doesn’t qualify. Its development history suggests it was platted and intended as a suburb or satellite settlement to Indianapolis centered on Butler University.

    Vacant tracts around it were later developed into the large industrial/commercial uses that now exist (International Harvester and other plants on Brookville along the south edge; Ford and other plants on English and Shadeland to the east/southeast edge).

  9. AmericanDirt

    CDC guy, I see what you’re getting at with Irvington. But by that rationale, neither would Mars Hill qualify, or University Heights, or Homecroft. These three very different neighborhoods are were all clearly conceived as satellites when Indianapolis was already the state’s most prominent city. Only a handful of places, such as Acton or New Augusta or maybe Bridgeport, may have had a genesis entirely independent of Indianapolis. Even tiny Julietta probably began as a workers’ community to serve the old sanitarium.

  10. cdc guy

    I get your point.

    I didn’t fully state my main point: that Augusta/New Augusta, Nora, Castleton all grew up around train depots in rural areas rather independently of Indianapolis. (It wouldn’t surprise me if the same were true of Cumberland, Julietta, New Palestine, Acton, and Clayton.)

    Irvington was always intended to be a suburb by its developers, just as were the original developments in Meridian Kessler (along the Broad Ripple streetcar line) and Butler Tarkington.

    However, remnant pre-WW2 commercial structures in either sort of area would give a “small town feel” in today’s city, so I guess I’m splitting hairs.

  11. Anonymous

    Having spent a good deal of my life within 5/10 both east & west of Raceway road, I would love to know more history regarding Bridgeport.

  12. AmericanDirt

    Thanks for the comment. It would be interesting to know more about Bridgeport, especially since there’s a collector road named after it. My guess is that, like the similarly tiny Julietta, there’s so little left–and so little will to salvage what remains–that any real historic records are tucked away in someone’s old attic. I’d love to be proven wrong though.

  13. Thomas

    Old post I’m replying to, but I’ve got a little bit of info about Bridgeport.

    Obviously it was a small rural enclave, but a decent number of residences that were located south of US 40 were demolished for airport expansion. That occurred around the same time as UNIGOV came along and put a pretty good dent in the town.

    The Post Office building that remains is not the original, but sits adjacent to where the original was. My great-grandfather was the Bridgeport Postmaster starting shortly after he got home from WW1 until he retired in the early 60’s. My great-grandmother was the window clerk there for nearly as long, until she passed away in the 50’s. The school was for all grades and it has been demolished in the last few years.

    The farmland immediately surrounding the town was dominated by a large greenhouse, owned by one family who’s name escapes me. Many who lived in the town worked at the greenhouse. It was also a predominantly Quaker community, much like Plainfield was at the time. It was a destination for Quakers who migrated to this region from the south during the late 19th and early 20th century.

    Hope some of this info was helpful!

  14. cdc guy

    Oaklandon is actually part of the excluded city of Lawrence; that annexation was part of the whole Unigov caper.

  15. Dean

    Just found this blog and think it’s wonderful.

    I grew up in Plainfield and know a little something about Bridgeport. One person posted that Unigov and the airport expansion happened at the same time. I went to IUPUI and still lived at home in Plainfield. I sometimes drove down Washington St (US 40) between the main campus downtown and home. There were still homes south of Washington St until the mid 1980’s when I was in college. I can remember seeing those homes being torn down for the airport expansion. The nursery that was mentioned was Hobbs Nursery. The main offices were at the intersection of Washington St and Raceway (aka Countyline) Rd. There is a nice write up about the nursery in the book The History of Hendricks County; 1914-1976. The nursery field were on both sides of Raceway Rd just to the west of Bridgeport.

  16. AmericanDirt

    Thanks for the feedback, Dean. It’s good to get additional insight on an increasingly marginalized little community within Indianapolis city limits, though it seems as though Bridgeport has been marginalized for quite some time. As you probably know, as Bridgeport has diminished, Plainfield has boomed. It now has about 30,000 people.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. You are not required to sign in. Anonymous posting is just fine.

Verified by MonsterInsights