Search
Search

Turnstile jumping: a mundane crime faces new hurdles in effective prevention.

It’s impossible to deny a sad truth for anyone who has used transit regularly in the last few years: the shameful act of turnstile jumping has reached epidemic levels in most cities where turnstiles serve as a primary means of fare collection.  And this includes almost any American city with light- or heavy-rail transit.  I don’t want to rely on anecdotes, but I’ve certainly seen its rise on the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority (WMATA) since COVID.  And I don’t even use the region’s Metro (subway) system frequently at all anymore, averaging only about once per month.  Even when I’m around one but not using it—when I just happen to walk by—I still routinely witness turnstile jumping.  Prior to COVID, in the approximately three years when I used the DC Metro system more frequently, I only recall seeing such an incident once.

For those who don’t routinely use WMATA, a subway, or even any form of mass transit—which, let’s face it, is the overwhelming majority of Americans—what does turnstile jumping even mean?  Also called (among other things) metro fare jumping, it is the act of bypassing the access control mechanism that ensures each individual preparing to ride transit has paid for that ride.  Whether electronic or mechanical, the essence of a turnstile is simple: if a person doesn’t pay, the gate doesn’t open and he or she can’t continue to the train platform.  Turnstiles operate differently across various metropolitan transit systems, but in metro Washington DC, users don’t pay a flat rate to ride; the price changes based on the distance of travel.  The machines calculate distance and fare by requiring passengers to flash their access card at the entrance (before embarking on a train) and at the exit (after they have departed all trains for the final time).  Passengers who make transfers from one train line to another do not need to show their access card; they are “in the hopper” of the Metro system as long as the artillery of turnstiles control their access.  And, if it turns out passengers don’t have enough money stored on his/her cards to get past that turnstile, the doors won’t open until they’ve paid the “Exitfare”, with a separate machine labelled for recharging the SmartTrip cards accordingly.

Turnstile jumping, therefore, is the act of evading fare payment by circumventing these machines and their access gates.  It always required somewhat deft maneuvering, since the whole point of those gates/arms is to preclude advancing until the machine swipes the card to indicate the beginning and end of a passenger’s trip.  But the decades-old previous Metro gates, with the signature orange “pie slice” arms, didn’t require a great deal of effort to overcome: individuals could treat the metallic card reader “arms” as a stable, flat surface, using both hands to vault themselves over those pie slices.  Small children could scramble under them.  But turnstile jumping didn’t happen frequently that I was aware of, at least through the late 2010s.  During the first year of COVID lockdowns, as civil unrest and anti-policing activism simultaneously reached their fever pitch, law enforcement’s ability diminished to both monitor stations and issue $50-$100 citations for turnstile jumping.  As word quickly spread regarding lax enforcement, the situation worsened: reporters at one station observed an incident approximately every two minutes, and WMATA estimated that by 2024 it was costing the system $40 million per year.  Furthermore, it amplified the “Broken Windows Theory” notion of a culture of leniency, so that one comparatively innocuous, non-violent defrauding act encouraged more pernicious, criminal behavior at this locus—up to and including violence.

Long percolating was a plan to upgrade the fare collection system to make crossing the gates safer, smoother, and more responsive to the chip-card system.  After the debacle of turnstile jumping became increasingly obvious, WMATA implemented a simultaneous plan in early 2021 to remove the old gates, replacing them with newer, significantly taller ones that are much more difficult to surmount.  Virtually all turnstiles had undergone this transformation by mid-year 2022.

Here’s an example of an upgrade at the Old Town (King Street) WMATA metro stop in Old Town Alexandria:

New 55" doors at WMATA stations (King Street) to prevent turnstile jumping

Coming from the same station as the photo at the top of this article, this saloon-door design demonstrates a marked improvement from the old pie slice arms that served as the DC Metro protocol for decades.  But the image to the left captures the second solution in the last few years: the original rollout in 2022-23, with 48” tall doors across all 1,200 turnstiles in the network, apparently did little to curb fare evasion.  So, less than a year later, WMATA announced a costly replacement model, measuring 55″ inches and deploying a polycarbonate material 200 times stronger than glass, which requires fare evaders to reach new levels of athleticism.

Is it working?  Empirical evidence says no.  At this densely populated, highly urban station in the most historic part of Alexandria, rife with crowds and queues, I still witnessed turnstile jumping during the time it took to snap a couple photos.  And the documented, reported evidence supports my eyewitness.  Yes, it is considerably harder to surmount the improved gates, but—to be frank—a young male of average height (or a tallish female) who is not significantly overweight is probably sufficiently long-legged and agile to leap up onto the card-reading arm, then sidle between two polycarbonate gates, all in about five seconds.

At the very least, are the law-breakers more exposed and obvious at the lower-density, outer suburban Metro stops—and thus the gates are more effective because the miscreants can’t get lost easily in a crowd?  I put this supposition to the test by venturing into nearby Fairfax County to visit the Franconia-Springfield Station, at the end of the blue line.

Compared to King Street and Old Town Alexandria, this area is almost entirely automobile-oriented.  Virtually no one would ever walk to the Franconia-Springfield station; passengers either pay for parking in the garage or have a companion drop them off at the kiss-and-ride point.

These passengers then climb the stairs to embark, since most of the WMATA network line is elevated in suburban Virginia.  And they encounter the same 55” gates as King Street, which WMATA rolled out in 2023, and, to the best of my understanding, is almost 100% complete in replacing from the 48” prototype introduced just a few years ago.

Turnstile jumping: new doors to prevent it don't seem to work

To capture these images, I lurked around Franconia-Springfield for a little more than five minutes.  It was a little after 9pm on a Monday, well past peak usage, and since this is a suburban stop at the end of the line, the overall ridership is likely always a bit more sparse.  But even during this time, I witnessed the same behavior that was comparatively rare in the late 2010s:

New 55" doors at WMATA stations (Franconia-Springfield) to prevent turnstile jumping

A “gentleman”, barely outside the margins of this photo, was standing around the nearly empty station, glancing alternately between his smart phone and me.  Maybe he had the Metro access app on his phone and was trying to use it.  But why keep looking at me?  As I was stepping away, I pivoted back around, and there he was, getting a running start so he could jump up on the one arm that lacked the digital card-reading device.  The gentleman got his feet up there, then sidled past the transparent doors.  If the WMATA workers visible in the far-right of the above photo saw his act of turnstile jumping, they didn’t care.  Where was security?

New 55" doors at WMATA stations (Franconia-Springfield) to prevent turnstile jumping

Therein lies the recurrent problem with Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED), a concept I have discussed in the past.  In most respects, these improved turnstile arms represent a strategy that undoubtedly curtails lawbreaking to an extent, and it’s unreasonable to inveigh against improvements that make the perfect the enemy of the good.  No design can fully thwart all turnstile jumping.  But it seems the taller, stronger saloon doors have only restricted those who are too old, too slow, or too short to find a workaround.  Where there’s a will to break the law—and sufficient athleticism—there will always be a way.  So I’ll ask again: “Where is the security?!”

A more recent article assessing the phenomenon of turnstile jumping has less to say about the door design, as though the WMATA authorities have capitulated and recognized they’ve done all they can to reduce turnstile jumping through physical impediments (minus barbed wire).  Now the citizenry are acknowledging “piggybacking”—where one person freeloads on the paid fare of another by backing into the open gate immediately behind the payer, resulting in two people getting past the arms off of one fare card swipe.  It can happen through complicity—a payer letting his/her buddy “piggyback” behind—or a complete stranger attempting to hijack the good will of an honest transit customer.  The only mechanical/design solution would be to make the doors open so sharply after a person enters that they could inadvertently clamp shut and injure a good-faith paying customer.  Thus, whether piggybacking or turnstile jumping, Metro police have ramped up enforcement, issuing 10,000 fare evasion citations in 2024, more than quadrupling the rate from the prior year when 48” gates were still the status quo.

Perhaps the crime prevention strategies boil down to returns on investment.  CPTED solutions are far more expensive upfront and probably achieve less of an overall reduction in fare evasion, but they are passive and require little maintenance.  And they definitely restrict the less nimble from breaking the law.  Meanwhile, security personnel issuing citations is more effective at reducing day-to-day fare evasion rates, but it requires an expensive operational cost of consistent human presence (often chasing the culprits amid crowds). It then requires a second enforcement layer to ensure the offenders pay their citations.

Perhaps the only true way for WMATA to counterbalance the cost of enforcement with the monetary loss through fare invasion would be a radical solution proposed (predictably) in the Reddit-sphere: make public transportation 100% free for everyone.  But that doesn’t nullify operational costs (obviously).  More importantly, merely eliminating the mechanism of value might obviate all theft (since there’s nothing to steal), but evidence elsewhere has shown that it doesn’t eliminate or even reduce any other criminal activity.  In fact, by becoming completely non-restrictive, it may only encourage the most anti-social to loiter around transit, scaring everyone else.  In a country where a mere 3.8% of commuters use transit as their primary means of getting to work, even the appearance of well-used systems helps make the case for the perpetuation of systems like WMATA.  At least the turnstile jumpers put more butts in seats.

Share this post

Share this post

18 thoughts on “Turnstile jumping: a mundane crime faces new hurdles in effective prevention.”

  1. Crystal Wible

    I had a friend who was violently assaulted when he told some teens to not do this. 🙁 I believe his nose was broken.

    Reply ↓
    1. AmericanDirt Post author

      yeah, piggybacking may be an even bigger problem, now that the new gates are difficult for some people to surmount. And it’s one thing when two friends sneak in on a single payment, but it’s much worse when some creep slither in right behind you and free loads off of you.

      Reply ↓
  2. MeetmeattheGOGO

    Nope it’s not working. Like you said it may have slowed down some of the older people but hasn’t stopped anyone who wants to do it. Those who can’t climb or hop over just piggyback. I’ve seen a few crawl under.

    Reply ↓
    1. AmericanDirt Post author

      Yeah, those who are too old or too short or too unathletic probably have a hard time now. But the group who are the biggest culprit—young nimble males—just have a fun new challenge. And, after one or two attempts, not even that challenging.

      Reply ↓
  3. Lynne Westergaard Stallcop

    I lived in DC for over two years and saw it all the time. These kids open the handicap gates and 7 walk through. One followed right behind me one time. We saw a Metro transit officer once writing up a jumper.

    Reply ↓
    1. AmericanDirt Post author

      That sounds like a common occurrence back when DC Metro primarily had the “orange pie slice” gates. Though this would be much harder to achieve with the new doors, my guess is a troop of 7-8 people could still walk through as piggybackers if bunched together–after all, it would be a massive liability issue to have a door shut on someone.

      Reply ↓
    2. Lynne Westergaard Stallcop

      I saw them hop over the orange pie slices too right before they put the doors in. And that evidently doesn’t work either. It’s sad and it’s stealing. They still hop up on the card scanner and jump between the doors. As I said, one piggybacked behind me.

      Reply ↓
      1. AmericanDirt Post author

        That almost feels like it could border on assault. I know the true insult is someone freeloading off of your effort to play by the rules, but a piggybacking often involves physical contact, which should constitute an offense. I can only imagine a piggybacker pushing over the paying customer.

        Reply ↓
      2. Lynne Westergaard Stallcop

        Yup. His arm brushed my shoulder. And this guy had a job, he was in scrubs and probably had a nicer phone than mine. Lol

        Reply ↓
  4. Kitty Hacker

    No! Now people sneak up behind me when I swipe my card and it makes me very uncomfortable. Why don’t you just copy the new York City turnstile instead of this dumb idea?

    Reply ↓
  5. Anonymous

    Nothing stops them from just jumping up in the middle and stepping over, see it every day, right in front of the officers. I’ve seen officers make direct eye contact with them and do nothing.

    New York turn style in the way

    Reply ↓
  6. Michelle Renay

    I was at NC metro station, coming off the escalator and literally saw a man crawling under those flaps. Now I’ve seen OVER and UNDER! 😂

    Reply ↓

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. You are not required to sign in. Anonymous posting is just fine.